Classification of railway accidents

Classification of railway accidents, both in terms of cause and effect, is a valuable aid in studying rail (and other) accidents to help to prevent similar ones occurring in the future. Systematic investigation for over 150 years has led to the railways' excellent safety record (compared, for example, with road transport).

Ludwig von Stockert (1913) proposed a classification of accidents by their effects (consequences); e.g. -on-collisions, rear-end collisions, derailments. Schneider and Mase (1968) proposed an additional classification by causes; e.g. driver's errors, signalmen's errors, mechanical faults. Similar categorisations had been made by implication in previous books e.g. Rolt (1956), but Stockert's and Schneider/Mase's are more systematic and complete. With minor changes, they represent best knowledge.

Classification of rail accidents by effects

• Collisions

  Collisions with trains:

  • Head-on collision
  • Rear-end collision
  • Slanting collision

  • Collisions with buffer stops (overrunning end of track)
  • Collisions with obstructions on the track (may also cause derailment)

  • Collision with landslips (in cuttings)

• Derailments

  By location:

  • Plain track
  • Curves
  • Junctions

Other

• Fires, explosions and release of hazardous chemicals (including sabotage/terrorism)
• People falling from trains, collisions with people on tracks

Classification of rail accidents by causes

Drivers' errors

• Passing signals at danger
• Excessive speed
• Mishandling of the engine (e.g. boiler explosions)
• Failure to check brakes and safety systems as well as sand reserve
• Failure to stop at required positions, e.g. level crossings with defective equipment or shunting movements that lead to occupied tracks.

Signalmen's errors

• Allowing two trains into same occupied block section
• Incorrect operation of signals, points or token equipment

(Mechanical) failure of rolling stock

• Poor design
• Poor maintenance
• Undetected damage
• Overloading or freight that is not adequately secured.
• Fire starting from combustion motors, electric cables or equipment, leaking fuel or cooling oil

Civil engineering failure

• Track (permanent way) faults
• Bridge and tunnel collapses
• Poor track or junction layout

Acts of other people

• Other railway personnel (shunters, porters, maintenance personnel, etc.)
• Non-railway personnel
• Accidental
  • Accidental track obstruction e.g. with road vehicles or by working construction vehicles
• Deliberate (vandalism, terrorism, suicide, extortion, sabotage)
  • Deliberate track obstruction, e.g. with road vehicles or (heavy) objects
  • Intentional damage to infrastructure like tracks, points or signals
  • Level crossing misuse
  • Trespassing
  • Attack

Natural causes

• Track obstruction or damage by landslides, avalanches, floods, trees
• Fog or snow that obscure signals or the current position of the train
• Wet leaves (or their remains) making the tracks slippery.

Contributory factors

• Strength of rolling stock
• Fire hazards or dangerous goods in the train, in involved road vehicles or the vicinity
• Effectiveness of brakes
• Inadequate rules

References

• Ludwig von Stockert (1913), Eisenbahnunfalle (Railway Accidents – a contribution to railway operating technology). Leipzig 1913.
• Schneider, Wolfgang; Armand Mase (1968). Katastrophen auf Schienen. In German, English translation 1979 by E.L. Dellow as Railway Accidents of Great Britain and Europe. Orell Fussli Verlag (German), David and Charles (English). SBN 7153 4791 8.
• Rolt, L.T.C. (1956). Red for Danger. Bodley Head / David and Charles / Pan Books. Later editions available.

This page was last edited on 18 November 2023, at 03:43