YouTube Encyclopedic
-
1/3Views:2 934 5012 320968
-
Why the UK Election Results are the Worst in History.
-
United Kingdom General Election Results (1945-2015)
-
GV311 (2014/15) Week 10: Political Parties and Elections – part 2
Transcription
Hello Internet The UK had an election we need to talk about because after the debates finished, the people voted and the ballots tallied the results were this: But parliament ended up looking like this: Which isn't, exactly, representative. And by not exactly, I mean at all. Red earned 30% of the vote and 36% of the seats, which is sort of close, but the rest is madness: Orange earned 8% of the vote but got one eighth of that while Yellow's 5% just about doubled, and purple earned 13% and got squat. Meanwhile blue's 37% of the people booted to 51% of the seats in parliament. The blue boost is even bigger when you consider that 51% of the seats gives basically 100% the control. How'd this happen? In the UK -- national elections aren't really national, they're a bunch of local elections. The UK is divided into constituencies, each of which elects one member of parliament (M.P.) to represent them. This local / national divide is where the trouble begins. Imagine a parliament with just three constituencies, and it's easy to see how it wouldn't always align with citizens. Some people think this sort of result is fine -- “it's all *about* winning local elections,” they’ll say. “Each M.P. represents their constituency.” And while the imbalance in this example is dumb, but it's the same problem in the real election and this same argument is given, but there are two more problems with it in reality land. 1) Few citizens have any idea who their MP is, they just know what party they voted for -- what party they want to represent their views on the national level. And pretending like it's a local election is a bit disingenuous. -- in practice it's an election for now the nation will run -- not really for who is going to represent a tiny part of it. and even if it were 2) The individual constituencies are worse at representing their citizens than parliament. Indulge this spreadsheet-loving nerd for a moment, will you? The difference between what a party earned at the polls and what they got in parliament is the amount of misrepresentation error. If we calculate all the errors for all the parties and add them up we can say the Parliament as a whole has 47% percentage points of misrepresentation error. That sounds bad looks like a utopian rainbow of diversity compared to any local election because the local elections have *one* winner. Out of the 650 constituencies 647 have a higher representation error than parliament. These are the only three that don't and they're really unusual for having so many of a single kind of voter in one place. Most places look the The Wrekin which is dead in the middle a mere one-hundred and one points off. Note that the winning candidate didn't reach a majority here. Which means more than half of constituencies elected their MP with a minority of voters. The worst is Belfast South at the bottom of the list. Hilariously unrepresentative. Less than a quarter of the voters get to speak for the entire place in parliament. This is the the lowest percentage an M.P. has ever been elected by. So when people argue that the UK election is a bunch of local elections 1) people don't act like it, and 2) It's even more of an argument that the elections are broken because they're worse on this level. These local elections are unrepresentative because of the terrible 'First Past the Post' voting system -- which I have complained mightily about and won't repeat everything here -- go watch the video -- but TL;DR it only 'works' when citizens are limited to two choices. Voting for any party except the biggest makes it more likely the biggest will win by a minority -- which is exactly what happened. That citizens keep voting for smaller parties despite knowing the result is against their strategic interests demonstrates the citizenry wants diverse representation -- but that successes is the very thing that's made this the most unrepresentative parliament in the history of the UK. People happy with the results argue the system is working fine -- of course they do. Their team won. Government isn't a sport where a singular 'winner' must be determined. It's a system to make rules that everyone follows and so, we need a system where everyone can agree the process is fair even if the results don't go in their favor. If you support a system that disenfranchises people you don't like and turbo-franchises people you do -- then it doesn't look like you sport representative democracy, it looks like you support a kind of dictatorship light. Where a small group of people (including you) makes the rules for everyone. But as it is now, on election day the more people express what they want the worse the system looks which makes them disengaged at best or angry at worst and GEE I CAN'T IMAGINE WHY. This is fixable, there are many, many better ways the UK could vote -- here are two that even keep local representatives. And fixing voting really matters, because this is a kind of government illegitimacy score -- and it's been going up and may continue to do so unless this fundamentally broken voting system is changed.
Scotland
- Scottish Parliament elections
Wales
- Senedd elections
Northern Ireland
- Northern Ireland Assembly elections
Greater London
- Greater London Authority elections
- Greater London Council elections
Local elections
Elections by year
- 1973
- 1975
- 1976
- 1995
- 1997
- 1998
- 1999
- 2000
- 2001
- 2002
- 2003
- 2004
- 2005
- 2006
- 2007
- 2008
- 2009
- 2010
- 2011
- 2013
- 2014
- 2015
- 2016
- 2017
- 2018
- 2019
- 2021
- 2022
- 2023
English elections by Council
- Adur local elections
- Allerdale local elections
- Alnwick local elections
- Amber Valley local elections
- Arun local elections
- Ashfield local elections
- Ashford local elections
- Aylesbury Vale local elections
- Babergh local elections
- Barking and Dagenham local elections
- Barnet local elections
- Barnsley local elections
- Barrow-in-Furness local elections
- Basildon local elections
- Basingstoke and Deane local elections
- Bassetlaw local elections
- Bath and North East Somerset local elections
- Bedford local elections
- Bedfordshire local elections
- Berwick upon Tweed local elections
- Bexley local elections
- Birmingham local elections
- Blaby local elections
- Blackburn with Darwen local elections
- Blackpool local elections
- Blyth Valley local elections
- Bolsover local elections
- Bolton local elections
- Boston local elections
- Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole Council elections
- Bournemouth local elections
- Bracknell Forest local elections
- Bradford local elections
- Braintree local elections
- Breckland local elections
- Brentwood local elections
- Brent local elections
- Bridgnorth local elections
- Brighton and Hove local elections
- Bristol local elections
- Broadland local elections
- Bromley local elections
- Bromsgrove local elections
- Broxbourne local elections
- Broxtowe local elections
- Buckinghamshire local elections
- Burnley local elections
- Bury local elections
- Calderdale local elections
- Cambridge local elections
- Cambridgeshire local elections
- Camden local elections
- Cannock Chase local elections
- Canterbury local elections
- Caradon local elections
- Carlisle local elections
- Carrick local elections
- Castle Morpeth local elections
- Castle Point local elections
- Central Bedfordshire local elections
- Charnwood local elections
- Chelmsford local elections
- Cheltenham local elections
- Cherwell local elections
- Cheshire local elections
- Cheshire East local elections
- Cheshire West and Chester local elections
- Chester local elections
- Chester-le-Street local elections
- Chesterfield local elections
- Chichester local elections
- Chiltern local elections
- Chorley local elections
- Christchurch local elections
- City of Durham local elections
- Colchester local elections
- Congleton local elections
- Copeland local elections
- Corby local elections
- Cornwall local elections
- Cotswold local elections
- County Durham local elections
- Coventry local elections
- Craven local elections
- Crawley local elections
- Crewe and Nantwich local elections
- Croydon local elections
- Cumbria local elections
- Dacorum local elections
- Darlington local elections
- Dartford local elections
- Daventry local elections
- Derby local elections
- Derbyshire local elections
- Derbyshire Dales local elections
- Derwentside local elections
- Devon local elections
- Doncaster local elections
- Dorset County Council elections
- Dorset Council elections
- Dover local elections
- Dudley local elections
- Ealing local elections
- Easington local elections
- East Cambridgeshire local elections
- East Devon local elections
- East Dorset local elections
- East Hampshire local elections
- East Hertfordshire local elections
- East Lindsey local elections
- East Northamptonshire local elections
- East Riding of Yorkshire local elections
- East Staffordshire local elections
- East Sussex local elections
- Eastbourne local elections
- Eastleigh local elections
- Eden local elections
- Ellesmere Port and Neston local elections
- Elmbridge local elections
- Enfield local elections
- Epping Forest local elections
- Epsom and Ewell local elections
- Erewash local elections
- Essex local elections
- Exeter local elections
- Fareham local elections
- Fenland local elections
- Forest Heath local elections
- Forest of Dean local elections
- Fylde local elections
- Gateshead local elections
- Gedling local elections
- Gloucester local elections
- Gloucestershire local elections
- Gosport local elections
- Gravesham local elections
- Great Yarmouth local elections
- Greenwich local elections
- Guildford local elections
- Hackney local elections
- Halton local elections
- Hambleton local elections
- Hammersmith and Fulham local elections
- Hampshire local elections
- Harborough local elections
- Haringey local elections
- Harlow local elections
- Harrogate local elections
- Harrow local elections
- Hart local elections
- Hartlepool local elections
- Hastings local elections
- Havant local elections
- Havering local elections
- Herefordshire local elections
- Hertfordshire local elections
- Hertsmere local elections
- High Peak local elections
- Hillingdon local elections
- Hinckley and Bosworth local elections
- Horsham local elections
- Hounslow local elections
- Huntingdonshire local elections
- Hyndburn local elections
- Ipswich local elections
- Isle of Wight local elections
- Islington local elections
- Kennet local elections
- Kensington and Chelsea local elections
- Kent local elections
- Kerrier local elections
- Kettering local elections
- King's Lynn and West Norfolk local elections
- Kingston upon Hull local elections
- Kingston upon Thames local elections
- Kirklees local elections
- Knowsley local elections
- Lambeth local elections
- Lancashire local elections
- Lancaster local elections
- Leeds local elections
- Leicester local elections
- Leicestershire local elections
- Lewes local elections
- Lewisham local elections
- Lichfield local elections
- Lincoln local elections
- Lincolnshire local elections
- Liverpool local elections
- Luton local elections
- Macclesfield local elections
- Maidstone local elections
- Maldon local elections
- Malvern Hills local elections
- Manchester local elections
- Mansfield local elections
- Medway local elections
- Melton local elections
- Mendip local elections
- Merton local elections
- Mid Bedfordshire local elections
- Mid Devon local elections
- Mid Suffolk local elections
- Mid Sussex local elections
- Middlesbrough local elections
- Milton Keynes local elections
- Mole Valley local elections
- New Forest local elections
- Newark and Sherwood local elections
- Newcastle upon Tyne local elections
- Newcastle-under-Lyme local elections
- Newham local elections
- Norfolk local elections
- North Cornwall local elections
- North Devon local elections
- North Dorset local elections
- North East Derbyshire local elections
- North East Lincolnshire local elections
- North Hertfordshire local elections
- North Kesteven local elections
- North Lincolnshire local elections
- North Norfolk local elections
- North Shropshire local elections
- North Somerset local elections
- North Tyneside local elections
- North Warwickshire local elections
- North West Leicestershire local elections
- North Wiltshire local elections
- North Yorkshire local elections
- Northampton local elections
- Northamptonshire local elections
- Northumberland local elections
- Norwich local elections
- Nottingham local elections
- Nottinghamshire local elections
- Nuneaton and Bedworth local elections
- Oadby and Wigston local elections
- Oldham local elections
- Oswestry local elections
- Oxford local elections
- Oxfordshire local elections
- Pendle local elections
- Penwith local elections
- Peterborough local elections
- Plymouth local elections
- Poole local elections
- Portsmouth local elections
- Preston local elections
- Purbeck local elections
- Reading local elections
- Redbridge local elections
- Redcar and Cleveland local elections
- Redditch local elections
- Reigate and Banstead local elections
- Restormel local elections
- Ribble Valley local elections
- Richmond upon Thames local elections
- Richmondshire local elections
- Rochdale local elections
- Rochford local elections
- Rossendale local elections
- Rother local elections
- Rotherham local elections
- Rugby local elections
- Runnymede local elections
- Rushcliffe local elections
- Rushmoor local elections
- Rutland local elections
- Ryedale local elections
- St Albans local elections
- St Edmundsbury local elections
- St Helens local elections
- Salisbury local elections
- Salford local elections
- Sandwell local elections
- Scarborough local elections
- Sedgefield local elections
- Sedgemoor local elections
- Sefton local elections
- Selby local elections
- Sevenoaks local elections
- Sheffield local elections
- Shepway local elections
- Shrewsbury and Atcham local elections
- Shropshire local elections
- Slough local elections
- Solihull local elections
- Somerset local elections
- South Bedfordshire local elections
- South Buckinghamshire local elections
- South Cambridgeshire local elections
- South Gloucestershire local elections
- South Derbyshire local elections
- South Hams local elections
- South Holland local elections
- South Kesteven local elections
- South Lakeland local elections
- South Norfolk local elections
- South Northamptonshire local elections
- South Oxfordshire local elections
- South Ribble local elections
- South Shropshire local elections
- South Somerset local elections
- South Staffordshire local elections
- South Tyneside local elections
- Southampton local elections
- Southend-on-Sea local elections
- Southwark local elections
- Spelthorne local elections
- Stafford local elections
- Staffordshire local elections
- Staffordshire Moorlands local elections
- Stevenage local elections
- Stockport local elections
- Stockton-on-Tees local elections
- Stoke-on-Trent local elections
- Stratford-on-Avon local elections
- Stroud local elections
- Suffolk local elections
- Suffolk Coastal local elections
- Sunderland local elections
- Surrey local elections
- Surrey Heath local elections
- Sutton local elections
- Swale local elections
- Swindon local elections
- Tameside local elections
- Tamworth local elections
- Tandridge local elections
- Taunton Deane local elections
- Teesdale local elections
- Teignbridge local elections
- Telford and Wrekin local elections
- Tendring local elections
- Test Valley local elections
- Tewkesbury local elections
- Thanet local elections
- Three Rivers local elections
- Thurrock local elections
- Tonbridge and Malling local elections
- Torbay local elections
- Torridge local elections
- Tower Hamlets local elections
- Trafford local elections
- Tunbridge Wells local elections
- Tynedale local elections
- Uttlesford local elections
- Vale of White Horse local elections
- Vale Royal local elections
- Wakefield local elections
- Walsall local elections
- Waltham Forest local elections
- Wandsworth local elections
- Wansbeck local elections
- Warrington local elections
- Warwick District Council elections
- Warwickshire local elections
- Watford local elections
- Waveney local elections
- Waverley local elections
- Wealden local elections
- Wear Valley local elections
- Wellingborough local elections
- Welwyn Hatfield local elections
- West Berkshire local elections
- West Devon local elections
- West Dorset local elections
- West Lancashire local elections
- West Lindsey local elections
- West Oxfordshire local elections
- West Somerset local elections
- West Sussex local elections
- West Wiltshire local elections
- Westminster local elections
- Weymouth and Portland local elections
- Wigan local elections
- Wiltshire local elections
- Winchester local elections
- Windsor and Maidenhead local elections
- Wirral local elections
- Woking local elections
- Wokingham local elections
- Wolverhampton local elections
- Worcester local elections
- Worcestershire local elections
- Worthing local elections
- Wychavon local elections
- Wycombe local elections
- Wyre local elections
- Wyre Forest local elections
- York local elections
Welsh elections by council
- Blaenau Gwent local elections
- Bridgend local elections
- Caerphilly local elections
- Cardiff local elections
- Carmarthenshire local elections
- Ceredigion local elections
- Conwy local elections
- Denbighshire local elections
- Flintshire local elections
- Gwynedd local elections
- Isle of Anglesey local elections
- Merthyr Tydfil local elections
- Monmouthshire local elections
- Neath Port Talbot local elections
- Newport local elections
- Pembrokeshire local elections
- Powys local elections
- Rhondda Cynon Taf local elections
- Swansea local elections
- Torfaen local elections
- Vale of Glamorgan local elections
- Wrexham local elections